Must-Try Dishes in Columbus, Ohio: A Local Foodie’s Guide

A Foodie’s Guide to Columbus, Ohio: 5 Iconic Dishes You Must Try

Columbus isn’t just the capital of Ohio; it’s a growing hub for culture, creativity, and most importantly, food. While the city might not get as much national attention as Chicago or New York, Columbus has quietly built a reputation as a hidden paradise for food lovers. Its culinary scene is a vibrant reflection of its diverse communities, with a mix of classic American comfort food, internationally inspired bites, and innovative new concepts.

If you're planning your next meal out or visiting Columbus for the first time, this guide is your roadmap to the city's must-try culinary landmarks. Here are five iconic dishes that truly define the Columbus foodie experience.

1. The Thurmanator – The Thurman Café

If there’s one dish every Columbus local insists you try, it’s the Thurmanator. Found at the legendary Thurman Café, this isn’t just a burger; it’s a culinary rite of passage. Since 1942, this family-owned pub has been serving up its no-frills, old-school charm alongside some of the biggest and most famous burgers in the country. The Thurmanator is their magnum opus: a colossal stack of beef, bacon, ham, mozzarella, and American cheese, all piled high on a bun that can barely contain it.

Why it’s famous: The Thurmanator’s fame goes far beyond Columbus. It has been a featured star on travel and food shows, earning a spot on national "must-eat" lists. Finishing one is a badge of honour among locals and visitors alike.

Quick Read: The Best Handmade Pasta in Ohio: Where to Find Authentic Italian Flavours

Pro tip: Bring a friend, or an extra-large appetite. The Thurmanator is famously a challenge to finish in one sitting. Don't be afraid to take a doggy bag; the leftovers are just as good.

Location: 183 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206. The original spot is a true Columbus institution, with a cosy, rustic interior that feels like a step back in time.

2. Nashville Hot Chicken – Hot Chicken Takeover

Looking for a spicy kick that will make your taste buds tingle? Look no further than Hot Chicken Takeover. This fast-casual spot was instrumental in bringing the Nashville-style hot chicken craze to Ohio, and they've perfected it. The chicken is fried to crispy perfection, incredibly juicy on the inside, and dusted with a signature spice blend that you can order at varying levels of heat.

Why it’s famous: Beyond the perfectly fried chicken, Hot Chicken Takeover is known for its community-focused culture. They’ve built a loyal following with their unique, no-frills approach, friendly staff, and commitment to creating a welcoming atmosphere. It’s a true Columbus success story that started with a simple, brilliant idea.

Best pairing: To combat the heat, be sure to grab their classic sides. The mac and cheese is creamy and rich, while the cool, tangy coleslaw is the perfect complement to the spicy chicken.

Locations: Multiple spots across Columbus, including a prime location in the bustling North Market. This makes it easy to grab a bite no matter where you are in the city.

3. Jeni’s Ice Cream – Salty Caramel

Columbus locals are fiercely proud to claim Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams as their own. Founded by Jeni Britton Bauer in 2002, this brand has become a national phenomenon, with pints sold in grocery stores across the country. While all their flavours are exceptional, the Salty Caramel is the iconic scoop that started it all. Its perfect balance of salty and sweet, combined with a rich, buttery texture, sets a new standard for ice cream.

Why it’s famous: Jeni’s commitment to using high-quality, whole ingredients and crafting each batch with care has earned it a devoted following. The Salty Caramel is a masterpiece of flavour and texture, a testament to Jeni's philosophy of "splendid" ice creams.

Try this too: Jeni’s is famous for its creative and seasonal flavours. Don't miss out on trying a scoop of their current seasonal offering, which often uses ingredients from local farms.

Locations: You’ll find Jeni’s shops all over Columbus, but a visit to the original location inside the historic North Market offers a true taste of the brand's roots.

4. Pierogi – Hubert’s Polish Kitchen at North Market

Columbus’s food scene wouldn’t be complete without celebrating its rich immigrant influences. At Hubert’s Polish Kitchen, a staple of the famous North Market, the pierogi are the undisputed stars of the show. These pillowy, handcrafted dumplings are a culinary tradition, lovingly filled with classics like potato and cheese or savoury meat, then pan-fried to a golden-brown perfection.

Why it’s famous: Hubert’s is renowned for its authenticity, serving up traditional Polish recipes that have been passed down through generations. The experience of enjoying these delicious, home-style dumplings in the vibrant, bustling atmosphere of North Market is what makes it truly special.

Foodie tip: For a truly authentic experience, pair your pierogi with Hubert's equally famous cabbage rolls or a bowl of their rich and savoury borscht.

Location: North Market, 59 Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215. This is the heart of Columbus's food scene, housing dozens of local vendors under one roof.

5. Spaghetti Carbonara – Basi Italia

Nestled in the cosy, charming neighbourhood of Italian Village, Basi Italia is a local gem that delivers refined Italian comfort food. It’s a go-to spot for both special occasions and casual weeknight dinners, known for its intimate patio and impeccable service. While everything on their menu is delicious, their Spaghetti Carbonara is a standout dish that perfectly exemplifies their approach. Made with al dente pasta, crispy pancetta, and a rich, creamy sauce finished with just the right touch of Parmesan, it's a dish that's both elegant and deeply satisfying.

Why it’s famous: Basi Italia has mastered the art of balancing fine dining with a welcoming, neighbourhood charm. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel like a regular on your first visit.

Pair it with: A glass of Italian red wine is the perfect complement to the rich and savoury flavours of the carbonara, making for an unforgettable dining experience.

Location: 811 Highland St, Columbus, OH 43215. The tucked-away location adds to its status as a hidden gem.

Why Columbus Belongs on Every Foodie’s Map

From oversized burgers that are a testament to American indulgence to authentic international fare that reflects its diverse community, Columbus offers a culinary journey that is both surprising and satisfying. The city's food scene is a true reflection of its culture: innovative, diverse, and welcoming. Whether you're a lifelong local or just stopping in for a weekend, these dishes should be at the very top of your must-eat list.

So, where will your first bite take you?

FAQ: Your Top Questions About the Columbus Food Scene Answered

Q: What food is Columbus, Ohio, known for?

A: Columbus is best known for its diverse and growing food scene, particularly for its legendary burgers (like The Thurmanator), innovative ice cream (Jeni’s), and a burgeoning selection of international cuisine, thanks to its diverse immigrant communities.

Q: Where do locals eat in Columbus?

A: Locals love spots that offer great food with a community vibe. Beyond the iconic places listed above, they frequent neighbourhood gems like The Pearl in the Short North and explore the wide variety of vendors at North Market for everything from gourmet coffee to authentic Ethiopian food.

Q: Is Columbus a good city for foodies?

A: Absolutely. Columbus has evolved into a fantastic city for foodies. The scene is both accessible and adventurous, with new restaurants, food trucks, and unique concepts opening regularly. It’s a city where you can find everything from a classic dive bar burger to a multi-course fine dining experience.